 |
Forbes
Asia
On The Cover/Top Stories
Lighten Up
China wants to go easy on energy by using LEDs. For now that
means a lot of imports.
Bob Johnstone, 10.17.05
At a recent investor conference in Boston,
Silicon Valley's Robert C. Walker asked his audience a trick question:
Is China (a) a land of 800 million poor peasants, (b) a giant factory
with plentiful cheap labor, or (c) the bleeding edge of the solid-state
lighting revolution? The
answer is, of course, all three. The
revolution he refers to is the transition, now under way, from Edison's
lightbulb to tiny chips called light-emitting diodes (LEDs). It began
with niche applications such as traffic lights and displays like the
Nasdaq screen in New York's Times Square. But industry experts predict
that energy-efficient LEDs will sooner or later sweep away all other
forms of lighting, up to and including household lights.
"China will be the first country to
adopt the solid-state lighting revolution," Walker says. "You're going
to see China first, the rest of Asia second, Europe third and the
U.S. last in adopting that technology." A bold call perhaps, but as
the chief executive of ELite Optoelectronics, a Sunnyvale, California
supplier of LEDs, and a senior adviser to the Chinese government's
solid-state lighting committee, it is one that Walker is qualified
to make. China's government
has pressing reasons for embracing solid-state lighting, which in
the West is still a fringe technology. Prime among them is the fact
that LEDs will consume roughly 50% to 80% less energy than conventional
(incandescent and fluorescent) lights. Rapid
economic growth is already outstripping China's ability to supply
energy. According to Wu Ling, the dynamic former medical doctor who
directs the China Solid-State Lighting Alliance, a Beijing nonprofit
organization that develops strategy for the government, 12% of electricity
currently goes to lighting. Wu
estimates that if over the next ten years LEDs were to take 30% of
China's lighting market, then the saving would be 58 billion kilowatt-hours
per year. She points out that that is almost as much as the yearly
output of the Three Gorges Dam, the world's largest power plant, under
construction at a cost of $24 billion. "Faced
with a great shortage of energy, the government will push solid-state
lighting," Wu says. And in China when the mandarins want something
to happen, they have all sorts of ways of making sure that it does.
Top-down strategies include financing,
both direct and indirect. Wu expects Beijing's next five-year plan,
to be announced at the end of October, to contain a major increase
in spending on solid-state lighting R&D at Chinese universities
and national institutes (up from the $17 million spent since the project
began in January 2003). Wu
estimates that $725 million has thus far been invested in China's
domestic solid-state lighting industry. Some of this is private investment,
but industry insiders believe much of the money has come from government
banks in the form of soft loans to LED startups.
Regulations--in both positive and negative
forms--are another powerful lever. For example, officials can mandate
that LEDs be used for certain applications, such as the illumination
of tourist landmarks like Beijing's Tiananmen Square. Or, where the
codes haven't caught up with technology, authorities can turn a blind
eye to early adoption. "China
is different, in terms of regulations," says Bingwen Liang, chief
executive of Nanjing Handson Semiconductor Lighting, a leading LED
packager and fixturemaker. "It's not so tight as in Europe or the
U.S. As long as you have good relationships with the leaders, anything
can happen." Also auguring
well for the rapid take-up of new lighting technology, Wu points out,
is that China's infrastructure is still a work in progress. "The whole
country is like a construction site," she says. "In
the U.S. I'm not going to go to the Marriott Hotel and have them change
their whole electrical system," Walker explains. "In China I get to
go to a guy who's building a new hotel and say, ‘Design your
building around LEDs.'" In
particular, the country is scrambling to prepare for the Olympics
in Beijing in 2008. These are billed as environmentally friendly games.
(Of necessity: It would be embarrassing if the city's appalling air
quality were to affect the health of athletes.) LEDs are among the
officially designated environmental technologies.
The Olympics are also an opportunity for
China to show itself off to the world. And it is in colorful outdoor
decorative lighting rather than general-purpose white illumination--the
implementation of which remains several years off--that the solid-state
revolution has initially been manifesting itself.
"The whole country's gearing up for the Olympics,
not just Beijing. They expect a lot of foreign tourists all over China,"
says Robert V. Steele, an analyst at Mountain View, California market
researcher Strategies Unlimited. "They want to dress up the country,
and they see LED lighting as a key element in improving the appearance
of buildings, bridges, fountains and ancient sites."
For example, the Full Moon Tower, a 52-meter
[170-foot] structure in Galaxy Park, Tianjin's civic center, is illuminated
at night by a dazzling computer-controlled colored light show. City
officials decided on an illuminated landmark to help raise the profile
of Tianjin, a port city of 10 million inhabitants about 200 kilometers
southeast of Beijing. In
urban centers across the country the story is the same. "Every single
local government is trying to do this kind of thing," says Xiao Guang
He, executive vice president of Dalian Lumei Optoelectronics, China's
second-largest LED maker. "If one lighting project turns out good,
then people just keep on copying. And the cost is now so low that
people can afford it." Outdoor
decorative lighting accounts for almost a quarter of the Chinese LED
market, which was worth $1.4 billion in 2004. In southeastern China's
Fujian Province alone, according to Xiao, consumption of white LEDs
is running at 500 million a month. Currently most of the LEDs and
fixtures used in China, especially the high-end ones, are imported.
Companies such as Cree (U.S.) and
Nichia (Japan) provide the LED chips, while architectural LED fixtures
are supplied by firms like Boston's Color Kinetics and Vancouver's
TIR Systems, which was responsible for lighting up Tianjin's Full
Moon Tower. Per annum the
LED market is growing at 40% in terms of units and 23% in sales. It
is serviced domestically by some 600 firms employing as many as 40,000
workers; almost all are small outfits at the low end of the industry,
doing labor-intensive jobs such as packaging LED chips.
But the Chinese are determined to work
their way up the value chain. Already four Chinese companies have
begun to produce their own chips, with maybe twice that number gearing
up to follow. Xiao's company, Lumei, leads the field, largely thanks
to having acquired the optoelectronic arm of AXT, a U.S. firm in Fremont,
California, for $9.6 million in 2003. For
the moment Lumei continues to make its LEDs in California. But the
technology is migrating across the Pacific, carried to the mainland
by returning Chinese-born, American-trained engineers. Xiao, for example,
formerly worked for U.S. lasermaker Spectra-Physics. Liang of Nanjing
Handson spent seven years at HP-Agilent. And
though they may be late starters, the Chinese can draw inspiration
from the success of their archrivals, the Taiwanese. The island has
rapidly made itself a force to be reckoned with in LEDs. Steele reckons
that around 40 Taiwanese companies now manufacture LEDs, including
Lite-On Technology, a member of FORBES ASIA's new Fabulous 50 list
of top-performing bigger corporations (Oct. 3).
"Four years ago, when I was telling
people about Taiwan and LEDs, everyone pooh-poohed me," Bob Walker
says. "Now nobody talks about this industry without mentioning Taiwan."
The same will soon be true of the mainland.
|
|